Comparative analysis of the outcome between aperture and suspensory graft fixation methods in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgeries: a systematic review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18203/issn.2455-4510.IntJResOrthop20242396Keywords:
ACL reconstruction, Aperture fixation, Suspensory fixation, Interference screws, Tightropes, Adjustable loops, Interference screw, EndobuttonAbstract
Human knee joint is a complex hinge joint which is relatively unstable compared to other joints of the body. The ligaments of the knee stabilize the joint during the different range of motion and are under continuous tension. This results in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) being injured during unnatural movement of the joint particularly in sports. With the advent of arthroscopy and better understating of ligament injuries with the use of MRI, the ligament reconstruction procedures have increased. The Reconstructive procedures for the ACL impart use of an Autograft which is secured in the bony tunnels of femur and tibia using various methods. As with any fixation these materials are subjected to various biological and mechanical forces. Suspensory or aperture graft fixation are the two most commonly employed methods in recent times. Both these methods have different tensile strengths and failure rates. Various studies have been conducted to assess the outcomes of these methods to evolve the most suitable and fail-safe method of securing the ACL allograft in the bony tunnels.
References
Amis AA. Anterolateral knee biomechanics. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthroscopy. 2017;25(4):1015-23.
Lin KM, Boyle C, Marom N, Marx RG. Graft selection in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Sports Med Arthroscopy Rev. 2020;28(2):41-8.
Claes S, Verdonk P, Forsyth R, Bellemans J. The “Ligamentization” process in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med. 2011;39(11):2476-83.
Zeng C, Lei G, Gao S, Luo W. Methods and devices for graft fixation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Cochrane Library. 2018;2018(6):CD010730.
Runer A, Keeling L, Wagala N, Hans N, Emre AÖ, Jonathan DH. Current trends in graft choice for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction-part I: anatomy, biomechanics, graft incorporation and fixation. J Exp Ortop. 2023;10:37.
Azar FM, Beaty JH, Canale ST. Campbell’s Operative Orthopaedics. 13th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier. 2017;2223.
O’Brien DF, Fones L, Stoj V, Edgar C, Coyner K, Arciero RA. Confirming proper button deployment of suspensory fixation during ACL reconstruction. Orthopaed J Sports Med. 2021;9(1):232596712097434.
Yao S, Fu BSC, Yung PSH. Graft healing after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Asia-Pacific J Sports Med Arthroscopy Rehabilit Technol. 2021;25:8-15.
Yao S, Yung PSH, Lui PPY. Tackling the challenges of graft healing after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction-Thinking from the Endpoint. Front Bioengineering Biotechnol. 2021;9:756930.
Kumar BR, Jd A, S HK. A comparative study of clinical and functional outcome of arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using hamstring graft with aperture fixation versus suspensory device fixation. Int J Orthopaed Sci. 2021;7(3):116-24.
Purohit1 S, Agrawal S, Gupta P. Comparison of outcome of interference versus suspensory fixation of hamstring tendon autografts on tibia during arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a tertiary care hospital. Int J Pharmaceut Clin Res. 2022;14(6);489-95.
Kashid M, Rahool S, Chaudhry A, Rajshekhar, Singh VB, Bhaskarwar AP. Comparative study between aperture and suspensary fixation of hamstring autografts on femoral side in ACL reconstruction: clinical and radiological outcome assessment. Int J Res Orthopaed. 2017;3(2):298.
Eichinger M, Ploner M, Degenhart G, Rudisch A, Smekal V, Attal R, et al. Tunnel widening after ACL reconstruction with different fixation techniques: aperture fixation with biodegradable interference screws versus all-inside technique with suspensory cortical buttons. 5-year data from a prospective randomized trial. Arch Orthopaed Trauma Surg. 2023;143(11):6707-18.
Panagopoulos A, Mylonas D, Kouzelis A, Zampakis P, Kraniotis P, Lakoumentas J, et al. No Difference in Outcomes Between Suspensory (Fixed-Loop Cortical Button) Versus Expandable Anteromedial Femoral Fixation in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction with Autologous Hamstring Tendons: A Prospective, Randomized, Controlled Study in Male Patients. Arthroscopy Sports Med Rehabilit. 2021;3(4):e1155-63.
Rai BK, Manav AK. Clinical and Functional Outcomes of Arthroscopic Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Using Hamstring Grafts Fixed with Aperture Vs Suspensory Device. Int J Pharmaceut Clin Res. 2021;13(6):55-63.
Lubowitz JH, Schwartzberg R, Smith P. Cortical Suspensory Button versus aperture Interference Screw Fixation for Knee anterior cruciate Ligament Soft-Tissue Allograft: A prospective, randomized Controlled trial. Arthroscopy. 2015;31(9):1733-9.
Browning WM, Kluczynski MA, Curatolo C, Marzo JM. Suspensory versus Aperture Fixation of a quadrupled hamstring tendon autograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: A Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2017;45(10):2418-27.
Crum RJ, De Sa D, Kanakamedala AC, Obioha OA, Lesniak BP, Musahl V. Aperture and suspensory fixation equally efficacious for quadriceps tendon graft fixation in primary ACL reconstruction: a Systematic review. J Knee Surg. 2019;33(07):704-21.
Buerba RA, Boden SA, Lesniak B. Graft selection in contemporary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. J Am Academy Orthopaed Surgeons Global Res Rev. 2021;5(10):e21.00230.
Vignos MF, Smith CR, Roth JD, Kaiser JM, Baer GS, Kijowski R, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament graft tunnel placement and graft angle are primary determinants of internal knee mechanics after reconstructive surgery. Am J Sports Med. 2020;48(14):3503-14.
Rayan F. Review of evolution of tunnel position in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. World J Orthoped. 2015;6(2):252.
Gupta R, Singh S, Kapoor A, Soni A, Kaur R, Kaur N. Graft tunnel integration occurs early in the tibial tunnel compared with the femoral tunnel after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with preserved insertion hamstring tendon graft. Knee Surg Rel Res. 2021;33(1):37.
Yao S, Fu BSC, Yung PSH. Graft healing after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Asia-Pacific J Sports Med Arthroscopy Rehabilit Technol. 2021;25:8-15.
Moretti L, Bizzoca D, Cassano GD, Caringella N, Delmedico M, Moretti B. Graft Intra-Articular Remodeling and Bone Incorporation in ACL Reconstruction: the state of the art and clinical implications. J Clin Med. 2022;11(22):6704.
McMellen CJ, Sinkler MA, Calcei JG, Hobson TE, Karns MR, Voos JE. Management of bone Loss and tunnel widening in Revision ACL reconstruction. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023;105(18):1458-71.
