Trauma outcomes at higher-level trauma centres compared with lower-level trauma centres: a systematic review and meta-analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18203/issn.2455-4510.IntJResOrthop20240424Keywords:
Trauma centers, Wounds and injuries, Epidemiology, Mortality, Complications, Systematic reviewAbstract
The introduction of trauma systems has helped reduce mortality in severely injured patients. This fall in mortality, however, appears to be concentrated in higher-level trauma centres (TCs) in comparison to lower-level TCs, but the evidence is inconsistent. Therefore, we undertook a systematic review with the aim of comparing outcomes in lower-level TCs (i.e. level III and IV trauma centres) with higher-level TCs (i.e. level I and II centres). This systematic review was performed in accordance with the guidelines defined in the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses statement (PRISMA). The review was registered on PROSPERO (CRD42019111933). Mortality data were combined using the Mantel-Haenszel random-effects method for meta-analysis, using Review Manager (RevMan v5.3.5). We found 28 eligible articles from an initial total of 10,816 identified abstracts. Our meta-analysis revealed no evidence of a difference in mortality risk in severely injured patients between lower-level and higher-level TCs (RR 1.55; 95% CI 0.97 to 2.50; p=0.07), but there was considerable heterogeneity (I2=92%) in the dataset. The risk of death in lower-level TCs in patients with neurological trauma, however, was statistically lower than in higher-level TCs (RR 0.80; 95% CI 0.73 to 0.86; I2=78%; p<00001). There was a higher risk of death in patients with neurological trauma managed at higher-level TCs and this is likely to be due to the higher severity of injury (intracranial and extracranial) sustained by patients at higher-level TCs. However, the high level of heterogeneity in the risk estimates of evaluated studies reduces the certainty of our interpretations.
References
World Health Organization. Injuries and violence. 2014. Available at: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/injuries-and-violence. Accessed on 14 December 2023.
Haagsma JA, Graetz N, Bolliger I, Naghavi M, Higashi H, Mullany EC, et al. The global burden of injury: incidence, mortality, disability-adjusted life years and time trends from the Global Burden of Disease study 2013. Inj Prev. 2016;22:3-18.
Department for Transport. Reported Road Casualties Great Britain: 2017. 2018. Available at: https://www.roadsafe.com/reportedroadcasualtiesgreatbritainannualreport2022#:~:text=The%20DfT%20unveil%20the%20final,return%20towards%20pre%2Dpandemic%20trends. Accessed on 14 December 2023.
Murray CJ, Richards MA, Newton JN, Fenton KA, Anderson HR, Atkinson C, et al. UK health performance: findings of the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010. The Lancet. 2013;381:997-1020.
American Trauma Society. Trauma Center Levels Explained. Available at: https://www.amtrauma. org/page/traumalevels. Accessed on 14 December 2023.
MacKenzie EJ, Rivara FP, Jurkovich GJ, Nathens AB, Frey KP, Egleston BL, et al. A national evaluation of the effect of trauma-center care on mortality. N Engl J Med. 2006;354:366-78.
Demetriades D, Martin M, Salim A, Rhee P, Brown C, Doucet J, et al. Relationship between American College of Surgeons trauma center designation and mortality in patients with severe trauma (injury severity score textgreater 15). J Am Coll Surg. 2006;202:212-5.
Gabbe BJ, Lyons RA, Lecky FE, Bouamra O, Woodford M, Coats TJ, et al. Comparison of mortality following hospitalisation for isolated head injury in England and Wales, and Victoria, Australia. PloS One. 2011;6:e20545.
Gabbe BJ, Biostat GD, Lecky FE, Bouamra O, Woodford M, Jenks T, et al. The effect of an organized trauma system on mortality in major trauma involving serious head injury: a comparison of the United Kingdom and Victoria, Australia. Ann Surg. 2011;253:138-43.
McKeating EG, Andrews PJ, Tocher JI, Menon DK. The intensive care of severe head injury: a survey of non-neurosurgical centres in the United Kingdom. Br J Neurosurg. 1998;12:7-14.
Patel HC, Bouamra O, Woodford M, King AT, Yates DW, Lecky FE, et al. Trends in head injury outcome from 1989 to 2003 and the effect of neurosurgical care: an observational study. Lancet. 2005;366:1538-44.
National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death. Trauma: who cares? 2007. Available at: https://www.ncepod.org.uk/2007t.html. Accessed on 14 December 2023.
Cole E, Lecky F, West A, Smith N, Brohi K, Davenport R, et al. The Impact of a Pan-regional Inclusive Trauma System on Quality of Care. Ann Surg. 2016;264:188-94.
Moran CG, Lecky F, Bouamra O, Lawrence T, Edwards A, Woodford M, et al. Changing the System - Major Trauma Patients and Their Outcomes in the NHS (England) 2008–17. E-Clin Med. 2018;2-3:13-21.
Dufresne P, Moore L, Tardif P-A, Razek T, Omar M, Boutin A, et al. Impact of trauma centre designation level on outcomes following hemorrhagic shock: a multicentre cohort study. Can J Surg J Can Chir. 2017;60:45-52.
Gomez D, Alali AS, Xiong W, Zarzaur BL, Mann NC, Nathens AB. Definitive care in level 3 trauma centres after severe injury: A comparison of clinical characteristics and outcomes. Injury. 2015;46:1790-5.
Cudnik MT, Newgard CD, Sayre MR, Steinberg SM. Level I versus Level II trauma centers: an outcomes-based assessment. J Trauma. 2009;66:1321-6.
Hill AD, Fowler RA, Nathens AB. Impact of interhospital transfer on outcomes for trauma patients: a systematic review. J Trauma. 2011;71:1885-900.
Pickering A, Cooper K, Harnan S, Sutton A, Mason S, Nicholl J. Impact of prehospital transfer strategies in major trauma and head injury: systematic review, meta-analysis, and recommendations for study design. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2015;78:164-77.
Polites SF, Leonard JM, Glasgow AE, Zielinski MD, Jenkins DH, Habermann EB. Undertriage after severe injury among United States trauma centers and the impact on mortality. Am J Surg. 2018;216:813-8.
Porter A, Karim S, Bowman SM, Recicar J, Bledsoe GH, Maxson RT. Impact of a statewide trauma system on the triage, transfer, and inpatient mortality of injured patients. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2018;84:771-9.
Ahmed N, Greenberg P, Johnson VM, Davis JM. Risk stratification of survival in injured patients with cardiopulmonary resuscitation within the first hour of arrival to trauma centre: retrospective analysis from the national trauma data bank. Emerg Med J. 2017;34:282-8.
Fakhry SM, Ferguson PL, Johnson EE, Wilson DA. Hospitalization in low-level trauma centres after severe traumatic brain injury: review of a population-based emergency department data base. Brain Inj. 2017;31:1486-93.
Roubik D, Cook AD, Ward JG, Chapple KM, Teperman S, Stone ME, et al. Then we all fall down: fall mortality by trauma center level. J Surg Res. 2017;217:36-44.
Barmparas G, Cooper Z, Haider AH, Havens JM, Askari R, Salim A. The elderly patient with spinal injury: treat or transfer? J Surg Res. 2016;202:58-65.
Distelhorst JT, Soltis MA, Krishnamoorthy V, Schiff MA. Hospital trauma level’s association with outcomes for injured pregnant women and their neonates in Washington state, 1995-2012. Int J Crit Illn Inj Sci. 2017;7:142-9.
Kane ED, Jeremitsky E, Pieracci FM, Majercik S, Doben AR. Quantifying and exploring the recent national increase in surgical stabilization of rib fractures. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2017;83:1047–52.
Jarman MP, Castillo RC, Carlini AR, Kodadek LM, Haider AH. Rural risk: Geographic disparities in trauma mortality. Surgery. 2016;160:1551-9.
Nelson-Williams H, Kodadek L, Canner J, Schneider E, Efron D, Haut E, et al. Do trauma center levels matter in older isolated hip fracture patients? J Surg Res. 2015;198:468-74.
Carr BG, Geiger J, McWilliams N, Reilly PM, Wiebe DJ. Impact of adding Level II and III trauma centers on volume and disease severity at a nearby Level I trauma center. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2014;77:764-8.
Bukur M, Felder SI, Singer MB, Ley EJ, Malinoski DJ, Margulies DR, et al. Trauma center level impacts survival for cirrhotic trauma patients. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2013;74:1133-7.
Gage AM, Traven N, Rivara FP, Jurkovich GJ, Arbabi S. Compliance with Centers for Disease Control and Prevention field triage guidelines in an established trauma system. J Am Coll Surg. 2012;215:148-54.
Cook A, Cade A, King B, Berne J, Fernandez L, Norwood S. Ground-level falls: 9-year cumulative experience in a regionalized trauma system. Proc Bayl Univ Med Cent. 2012;25:6-12.
Egol KA, Tolisano AM, Spratt KF, Koval KJ. Mortality rates following trauma: The difference is night and day. J Emerg Trauma Shock. 2011;4:178-83.
Garwe T, Cowan LD, Neas B, Cathey T, Danford BC, Greenawalt P. Survival benefit of transfer to tertiary trauma centers for major trauma patients initially presenting to nontertiary trauma centers. Acad Emerg Med Off J Soc Acad Emerg Med. 2010;17:1223-32.
Hotaling JM, Wang J, Sorensen MD, Rivara FP, Gore JL, Jurkovich J, et al. A national study of trauma level designation and renal trauma outcomes. J Urol. 2012;187:536-41.
Helling TS. Trauma care at rural level III trauma centers in a state trauma system. J Trauma. 2007;62:498-503.
Nirula R, Brasel K. Do trauma centers improve functional outcomes: a national trauma databank analysis? J Trauma. 2006;61:268-71.
Mckee JL, Roberts DJ, van Wijngaarden-Stephens MH, Vis C, Gao H, Belton KL, et al. The right treatment at the right time in the right place: a population-based, before-and-after study of outcomes associated with implementation of an all-inclusive trauma system in a large Canadian province. Ann Surg. 2015;261:558-64.
Amini R, Lavoie A, Moore L, Sirois M-J, Emond M. Pediatric trauma mortality by type of designated hospital in a mature inclusive trauma system. J Emerg Trauma Shock. 2011;4:12-9.
Vassallo J, Webster M, Barnard EBG, Lyttle MD, Smith JE. Epidemiology and aetiology of paediatric traumatic cardiac arrest in England and Wales. Arch Dis Child. 2018;314985.
Metcalfe D, Gabbe BJ, Perry DC, Harris MB, Ekegren CL, Zogg CK, et al. Quality of care for patients with a fracture of the hip in major trauma centres: a national observational study. Bone Jt J. 2016;98-B:414-9.
Gomes E, Araújo R, Carneiro A, Dias C, Lecky FE, Costa-Pereira A. Mortality Distribution in a Trauma System: From Data to Health Policy Recommendations. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg Off Publ Eur Trauma Soc. 2008;34:561-9.
Curtis KA, Mitchell RJ, Chong SS, Balogh ZJ, Reed DJ, Clark PT, et al. Injury trends and mortality in adult patients with major trauma in New South Wales. Med J Aust. 2012;197:233-7.
Curtis K, Chong S, Mitchell R, Newcombe M, Black D, Langcake M. Outcomes of severely injured adult trauma patients in an Australian health service: does trauma center level make a difference? World J Surg. 2011;35:2332-40.
Minei JP, Fabian TC, Guffey DM, Newgard CD, Bulger EM, Brasel KJ, et al. Increased trauma center volume is associated with improved survival after severe injury: results of a Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium study. Ann Surg. 2014;260:456-64.
Bell TM, Boustany KC, Jenkins PC, Zarzaur BL. The relationship between trauma center volume and in-hospital outcomes. J Surg Res. 2015;196:350-7.
Morche J, Mathes T, Pieper D. Relationship between surgeon volume and outcomes: a systematic review of systematic reviews. Syst Rev. 2016;5:204.
Dumas RP, Seamon MJ, Smith BP, Yang W, Cannon JW, Schwab CW, et al. The epidemiology of emergency department thoracotomy in a statewide trauma system: Does center volume matter? J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2018;85:311-7.
Ball CG, Sutherland FR, Dixon E, Feliciano DV, Datta I, Rajani RR, et al. Surgical trauma referrals from rural level III hospitals: should our community colleagues be doing more, or less? J Trauma. 2009;67:180-4.
McDermott F, Cordner S, Winship V. Addressing inadequacies in Victoria’s trauma system: Responses of the Consultative Committee on Road Traffic Fatalities and Victorian trauma services: Improving Victoria’s trauma system. Emerg Med Australas. 2010;22:224-31.
Olson CJ, Arthur M, Mullins RJ, Rowland D, Hedges JR, Mann NC. Influence of trauma system implementation on process of care delivered to seriously injured patients in rural trauma centers. Surgery. 2001;130:273-9.
Liberman M, Mulder DS, Jurkovich GJ, Sampalis JS. The association between trauma system and trauma center components and outcome in a mature regionalized trauma system. Surgery. 2005;137:647-58.
Dinh MM, Bein KJ, Gabbe BJ, Byrne CM, Petchell J, Lo S, et al. A trauma quality improvement programme associated with improved patient outcomes: 21 years of experience at an Australian Major Trauma Centre. Injury. 2014;45:830-4. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2013.11.005.
Daniel CO, West TA, Craig-Blanco PS, Myers JG, Stewart RM. Full time trauma service leads to improved Level III trauma center outcomes. Am J Surg. 2010;200:734-9.
Bledsoe BE, Casey MJ, Feldman J, Johnson L, Diel S, Forred W, et al. Glasgow Coma Scale Scoring is Often Inaccurate. Prehospital Disaster Med. 2015;30:46-53.
Reith FCM, Van den Brande R, Synnot A, Gruen R, Maas AIR. The reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale: a systematic review. Intensive Care Med 2016;42:3-15.
Rau C-S, Wu S-C, Chen Y-C, Chien P-C, Hsieh H-Y, Kuo P-J, et al. Effect of Age on Glasgow Coma Scale in Patients with Moderate and Severe Traumatic Brain Injury: An Approach with Propensity Score-Matched Population. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017;14.
DuBose JJ. Effect of Trauma Center Designation on Outcome in Patients With Severe Traumatic Brain Injury. Arch Surg. 2008;143:1213.
Varelas PN, Eastwood D, Yun HJ, Spanaki MV, Hacein Bey L, Kessaris C, et al. Impact of a neurointensivist on outcomes in patients with head trauma treated in a neurosciences intensive care unit. J Neurosurg. 2006;104:713-9.
Leitgeb J, Mauritz W, Brazinova A, Majdan M, Wilbacher I. Impact of concomitant injuries on outcomes after traumatic brain injury. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2013;133:659-68.
Varma A, Hill EG, Nicholas J, Selassie A. Predictors of Early Mortality After Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury: A Population-based Study. Spine. 2010;35:778-83.
Bellabarba C, Fisher C, Chapman JR, Dettori JR, Norvell DC. Does early fracture fixation of thoracolumbar spine fractures decrease morbidity or mortality? Spine. 2010;35:S138-45.
Mitchell RJ, Curtis K, Testa L, Holland AJ, Sv Soundappan S, Adams S. Differences in survival outcome for severely injured paediatric trauma by type of trauma centre. J Paediatr Child Health. 2017;53:808-13.
Webman RB, Carter EA, Mittal S, Wang J, Sathya C, Nathens AB, et al. Association Between Trauma Center Type and Mortality Among Injured Adolescent Patients. JAMA Pediatr. 2016;170:780-6.
Ovalle F, Xu L, Pearson WS, Spelke B, Sugerman DE. Outcomes of pediatric severe traumatic brain injury patients treated in adult trauma centers with and without added qualifications in pediatrics - United States, 2009. Inj Epidemiol. 2014;1:15.
Miyata S, Haltmeier T, Inaba K, Matsushima K, Goodhue C, Bliss DW. Should All Severely Injured Pediatric Patients be Treated at Pediatric Level I Trauma Centers? A National Trauma Data Bank Study. Am Surg. 2015;81:927-31.
McCarthy A, Curtis K, Holland AJA. Paediatric trauma systems and their impact on the health outcomes of severely injured children: An integrative review. Injury. 2016;47:574-85.
Li Y, Liu C, Xiao W, Song T, Wang S. Incidence, Risk Factors, and Outcomes of Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia in Traumatic Brain Injury: A Meta-analysis. Neurocrit Care. 2020;32:272-85.
Scheetz LJ. Complications and Mortality Among Correctly Triaged and Undertriaged Severely Injured Older Adults With Traumatic Brain Injuries. J Trauma Nurs Off J Soc Trauma Nurses. 2018;25:341-7.
